Home
  • Home
  • Latest Issue
  • Past Issues
  • Authors & Artists
  • Articles
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Forums
  • Search

Why Are You Calling Me a Barbarian?

  • View
  • Rearrange

Digital version – browse, print or download

Can't see the preview?
Click here!

How to print the digital edition of Books for Keeps: click on this PDF file link - click on the printer icon in the top right of the screen to print.

BfK Newsletter

Receive the latest news & reviews direct to your inbox!

BfK No. 122 - May 2000

Cover Story
This issue’s cover shows Jane Simmons’ popular character, Daisy, and her baby brother Pip. Two Daisy books with their ‘dynamic yet affectionate pictures’ full of painterly exuberance are reviewed in this issue. Thanks to Orchard Books for their help in producing this May cover.

  • PDFPDF
  • Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version
  • Send to friendSend to friend

Why Are You Calling Me a Barbarian?

Birgitta Petrén, Elisabetta Putini and Mary Becker
 Lara Artone and Monica Barsotti
(Getty Publications)
60pp, FICTION, 978-0892365593, RRP £11.99, Paperback
8-10 Junior/Middle
Buy "Why are You Calling Me a Barbarian?" on Amazon

This book offers contrasted accounts of children's lives in Imperial Rome and in Scandinavia in the 3rd century AD. The narrators are two children, one the daughter of a slave in the household of a Roman general; the other the son of a Scandinavian merchant. The text, originally in Italian and intended for 8-10 year olds, is written by two authors and lacks cohesion. It also lacks precision. This arises partly from trying to be true to the view of child narrators, whose knowledge would be limited, and partly from the cartoon illustrations, which do not suit a text that requires that differences in environment and social behaviour be shown clearly. The approach is anachronistically Pan-European: the point being that those whom the Romans regarded as barbarians had civilisations of their own. A good proposition, but an unconvincing way to present it. There is no index and a poor contents page, with inscrutable chapter headings like 'Mosquitoes at War', which makes the extraction of specific information impossible.

Reviewer: 
Clive Barnes
2
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Help/FAQ
  • My Account