Home
Blood Red Road Banner Ad
  • Home
  • Latest Issue
  • Past Issues
  • Authors & Artists
  • Articles
  • Reviews
  • News
  • Forums
  • Search

Thomas the Tank Engine - 65th anniversary edition

Digital version – browse, print or download

BfK Newsletter

Receive the latest news & reviews direct to your inbox!

BfK No. 184 - September 2010
BfK 184 September 2010

Cover Story
This issue’s cover illustration is from Nick Sharrat’s One Fluffy Baa-Lamb, Ten Hairy Caterpillars. Nick Sharratt is interviewed by Joanna Carey. Thanks to Alison Green Books for their help with this September cover.

Digital Edition
By clicking here you can view, print or download the fully artworked Digital Edition of BfK 184 September 2010.

  • PDFPDF
  • Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version
  • Send to friendSend to friend
  • Login or register to bookmark

Thomas the Tank Engine - 65th anniversary edition

Rev W Awdry
Illustrated by C Reginald Dalby
(Egmont Books Ltd)
80pp, 978-1405252683, RRP £14.99, Hardcover
5-8 Infant/Junior
Buy "Thomas the Tank Engine" on Amazon

Thomas the Bank Engine loved driving down the High Street to where the Fat Director kept his money. He liked to pull lots of trucks, especially if they were loaded down with bags of golden sovereigns, and Mr Egmont, the Fat Director’s own director, liked to think up new wheezes to keep the trucks well loaded. In this instance he has thought up a pretty way to celebrate Thomas’s 65th birthday by reproducing the four stories about him that first came out in 1946 (they can’t do maths on that railway), printing them in a larger format than is customary, slapping them into a handsome binding, and tucking the lot into a smart, colourful slip-case. The edition is said to be ‘limited’, but we are not told to how many copies.

The Fat Director probably won’t want to hear his customers murmur the word ‘pretentious’ (if he knows what it means), but, along with the mathematics, the thinking behind this enterprise is slipshod to a degree unfitting for a seriously celebratory volume. A meagre nine pages, begirt with questionably ‘rare artwork’, go nowhere in telling the intriguing story of the making of the book. Material appears to have been taken from Brian Sibley’s exhaustive study, The Thomas the Tank Engine Man (1995), which is nowhere acknowledged. And, as we learn from that book, the edition of Thomas published 64 years ago was illustrated by one Reginald Payne, while Mr Egmont is selling us a later reworking with the plates tidied up by the chap who became the regular series illustrator. Back in those days the Rev. Awdry had a hard time of it -- an innocent novice being ripped off by his publisher and, to some extent, his agent. Now in heaven, he’s probably groaning about even more indignities.

Reviewer: 
Brian Alderson
3
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Help/FAQ
  • My Account
website developed by purkiss