Books For Keeps
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Articles
  • Past Issues
  • Latest Issue
  • Authors and Artists
  • Latest News
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
March 1, 2002/in Editorial /by Richard Hill
This article is featured in BfK 133 March 2002
This article is in the Editorial Category

Editorial 133: March 2002

Author: Rosemary Stones
Philip Pullman’s The Amber Spyglass, the final part of his powerful moral epic, ‘His Dark Materials’ which won the Whitbread Children’s Book of the Year category, has gone on to win the Whitbread Book of the Year – beating the winners of the adult novel, first novel, poetry and biography sections. Philip Pullman is thus the first children’s author to win this prestigious prize which only recently changed its rules (after lobbying by Pullman and others) to allow children’s books to compete on equal terms with adult books. In this agreeable way, public recognition has at last been given to the fact that writers for children can and do produce demanding books of great literary quality.

This splendid win, together perhaps with the sight of adults on trains and buses engrossed in a Pullman novel or a Harry Potter, has even led to excited claims that such books blur the edges between publishing for adults and publishing for children. But do they really?

Pullman is quoted in The Independent (23 Jan. ’02) just after his Whitbread triumph as saying: ‘We don’t know how to view children. For example, there was a terrible fuss when Melvin Burgess brought out a book about a teenage girl who turns into a dog that has sex*. He also wrote a book in which – horror of horrors – teenage kids take heroin and suffer the consequences of addiction**. The fuss arises because we believe this is something that children ought not to know about and be protected from. There is no realistic view of children which encompasses the fact that they don’t know very much about the world and the fact that they’re beset by all kinds of temptations and they’re no better or worse than us… I know that they think deeply about things that they don’t have the experience to cope with yet.’

Certainly literature provides us all with opportunities to place our individual experience into a wider social or emotional context. For children in particular, books can be safely distanced ways of learning about and/or reflecting on all kinds of experiences or feelings, whether difficult, worrying, painful or exciting. But should warnings be given about a possibly contentious content or approach when a book published on a children’s list is under discussion? Can a blurring sometimes be inappropriate?

In BfK No.131 I reviewed Benjamin Lebert’s Crazy, an autobiographical novel written when the author was 16. As I wrote about this gripping and melancholic book it did not occur to me to mention, so integral a part of the story did it seem, that the schoolboy hero has sex with a girl. I was then, reading this ‘children’s book’ as though it were for adults. The edges were very much blurred.

But BfK is, of course, a children’s literature review journal and its readership is largely made up of those powerful gatekeepers and arbitrators of ‘suitable’ reading matter for the young – librarians, teachers and parents. Three readers, who use our recommendations as a buying guide, have written to complain that I did not alert them to the sexual content in this book (see Letters to the Editor, page 15). I think I should have done and I apologise – BfK does aim to provide the information that our readership needs about the books discussed in our pages. I do not, however, agree at all with their view that the sexual content of the book is pornographic – I find the passage in question full of anguish and confusion in which peer pressure clearly plays a part. This is very far from titillation.

To my mind, if there is a difference between books for adults and books for children, it lies in the possibility/probability of an experience being conveyed for the first time to a young reader who may not have the cultural, emotional and other reference points that are part of what an adult reader can bring to text. An additional complication lies in what Philip Pullman describes as a ‘realistic view’ of children. There is no one child reader to whom we can refer and this is where the experience of the adult ‘gatekeepers’ is much needed in relation to the children they work with, as well as their respect for a ‘realistic view’.

As Father Stephen Darlington points out in his helpful letter, the issue of ‘suitability’ versus censorship must be part of our concern about what is available to children. The easy way out for writers, not to speak of teachers, librarians and reviewers, is to avoid anything that might cause trouble. Young readers would not thank us for such fearfulness.

* Lady, My Life as a Bitch

** Junk

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
http://booksforkeeps.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/bfklogo.png 0 0 Richard Hill http://booksforkeeps.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/bfklogo.png Richard Hill2002-03-01 10:00:052021-12-02 13:07:31Editorial 133: March 2002
BfK 254 May 2022 Download BfK Issue BfK 254 May 2022
Skip to an Issue:

Related Articles

Editorial 254: May 2022
BfK 254 May 2022
Editorial 253: March 2022
BfK 253 March 2022
Editorial 252: January 2022
BfK 252 January 2022
Editorial 251: November 2021
BfK 251 November 2021
Guest Editorial 250: September 2021
BfK 250 September 2021
Editorial 249: July 2021
BfK 249 July 2021
Life-Changing Libraries: Making a start
BfK 249 July 2021
Guest Editorial 248: May 2021
BfK 248 May 2021

About Us

Launched in 1980, we’ve reviewed hundreds of new children’s books each year and published articles on every aspect of writing for children.

Read More

Follow Us

Latest News

Peter Bently and Steven Lenton named winners of The Children’s Book Award 2022

June 27, 2022

Shortlist for the 2022 SLA Information Book Award

June 23, 2022

2022 Yoto Carnegie Greenaway Winners Announced

June 16, 2022

Contact Us

Books for Keeps,
30 Winton Avenue,
London,
N11 2AT

Telephone: 0780 789 3369

ISSN: 0143-909X (this is our International Standard Serial Number).

© Copyright 2022 - Books For Keeps | Proudly Built by Lemongrass Media - Web Design Buckinghamshire
Under Taliban Rule Classics in Short No.33: Captain Slaughterboard Drops Anchor
Scroll to top