Books For Keeps
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Articles
  • Past Issues
  • Latest Issue
  • Authors and Artists
  • Latest News
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
July 1, 1983/in /by Richard Hill
This article is featured in BfK 21 July 1983
This article is in the Category

John Mason’s New York Diary – July 1983

Author: John Mason
Eat your hearts out, BFK readers – a few mornings ago I sat at breakfast table with Christopher Reeve, star of Superman! The occasion was the presentation of the children’s books section of the prestigious American Book Awards, and Christopher Reeve was the presenter. It was all part of the award promoters’ efforts to hype up the occasion and attract media coverage – and they did succeed in getting two of the big three national TV networks to film parts of it for their evening news slots, TV viewers were unaware, however, of the heated controversy in the children’s publishing community that had preceded the event. Some time previously the awards planning committee had decided to hold the ceremony in a newly-converted wing of the New York Public Library, but no one had bothered to check on exactly how big the rooms were or when they would be ready. A few weeks before the ceremony – with all the press releases out – it was discovered that the largest available room was less than half the required size!

Hastily the committee decided to split the ceremony into several sections, with the children’s books at a breakfast entirely separate from the Academy Awards-style main evening presentations. Children’s publishers returning from Bologna Book Fair were furious to find their books and authors relegated to what they viewed as a patronizing “kiddies’ corner” divorced from the main “grown-up” ceremony. Last-ditch efforts to reverse the plan failed while sharp words flew around the table and angry letters were exchanged. Next year, we’re assured, things will be better managed. Meanwhile, I’m happy to report that Christopher Reeve is as clean-living in real life as he is as Superman – he didn’t even drink coffee at breakfast, and ate only fresh melon!

Incompetent

At a talk in New York recently on “English vs. American Children’s Book Criticism”, Brian Alderson, children’s book reviewer of The Times, castigated most children’s book reviewing as “superficial and incompetent, bland and insipid”. Not enough space is devoted to children’s books in major newspapers, he said – The Times itself included – so that thoughtful, in-depth reviews rarely see the light of day. In addition, most reviewers themselves, claimed Alderson, don’t treat children’s books seriously or read them carefully. For example, in a comparison of reviews of Alan Garner’s The Aimer Gate, Alderson found that several well-known, highly regarded British critics – and I’d better not mention any names here! – had made fundamental errors of fact in their reviews. (The novel is set in 1916; one reviewer placed it in the Boer War, another in the 1920s.) Even publishers are not immune, sometimes making errors in the blurbs on their own books. Alderson was no kinder to American critics, alleging that their professional scholarly reference works, which they study so seriously, are riddled with inaccuracies.

Stereotype

Where does selection end and censorship begin? The distinction was blurred in a recent article in The New York Times with the provocative heading: “When Librarians Ban Books”. The article described how several major library systems had decided not to stock copies of a book called Jake and Honeybunch Go to Heaven, by Margot Zemach. The brightly illustrated picture book, which has caused a raging controversy here, depicts a happy-go-lucky black man and his mule who die and subsequently have a wild time settling into their new life in Heaven – where God, St Peter and all the angels are black, too. Critics have deplored Zemach’s depiction of the black Heaven with its “Glory Road”, “Pearly Gates” and “Heavenly Green Pastures”, and its very down-to-earth angels in everyday clothes playing jazz and cooking chicken-and-ribs dinners, as racial stereotypes. The publishers, Farrar Strauss & Giroux, counter that the book is firmly based on black American folklore.

Folklore reduced to such a simplistic level is clearly offensive to some, though as a work of art the book is exuberant, splashy and a lot of fun. The unresolved question is whether librarians can be expected to select books on their individual merits or whether they are inevitably – perhaps rightfully – influenced against a book which they feel will be offensive to some of their patrons, even if this involves denying others the opportunity to have access to it. It’s an area of judgement where there can be no definitive guidelines – conflicting pressures in society lead to conflicting library selection policies.

Kid-tested

What happens when a major toy company goes into children’s book publishing? Well, they go about it in an entirely different way from traditional publishers. Parker Brothers, the Massachussetts-based toy company that also manufactures Monopoly and other board games, recently acquired the publishing licence for the Care Bears, a new set of characters brought to life by General Mills and American Greetings, joint creators of the phenomenally successful Strawberry Shortcake. The new character merchandising effort features a family of ten cuddly-cute bears with symbols representing personality traits on their protruding bellies – Tenderheart Bear, for instance, has a red heart on its tummy – designed to help children deal with changing emotions. Parker Brothers spent many months doing market research with teachers, psychologists, parents and kids themselves to pin down the most popular story lines – or, as their ad in the industry magazine Toy and Hobby World puts it, “kid-tested for sure sales”.

Now that the “product” has been “developed”, Parker is gearing up for a one-million dollar TV advertising blitz – over one-third the total sum spent in advertising last year by the entire children’s book industry – focused on just six titles. Parker plans to sell the books mainly through toy shops and supermarkets rather than bookshops. “We’re going to revolutionize the kids’ book industry,” states their marketing director James Buchanan. Publishers watch out!

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
http://booksforkeeps.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/bfklogo.png 0 0 Richard Hill http://booksforkeeps.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/bfklogo.png Richard Hill1983-07-01 09:15:042021-12-14 18:26:09John Mason’s New York Diary – July 1983
Download BfK Issue Bfk 272 May 2025
Skip to an Issue:

Related Articles

No Related Articles

About Us

Launched in 1980, we’ve reviewed hundreds of new children’s books each year and published articles on every aspect of writing for children.

Read More

Follow Us

Latest News

Effervescent, scintillating, riveting!’ Collection of ‘colossal’ word poems wins the CLiPPA

June 20, 2025

Winners of the 2025 Carnegie Medals announced

June 19, 2025

Inclusive Books for Children book-gifting scheme expands again

June 18, 2025

Contact Us

Books for Keeps,
30 Winton Avenue,
London,
N11 2AT

Telephone: 0780 789 3369

ISSN: 0143-909X (this is our International Standard Serial Number).

© Copyright 2025 - Books For Keeps | Proudly Built by Lemongrass Media - Web Design Buckinghamshire
May We Recommend… Nina Beachcroft Here Comes Summer
Scroll to top